Section i investigates the appearance of the theme of gods death in lutheran theology. Third, while the moral god is dead, this does not put an end to the godquestion. While hegel and nietzsche worked within the same intellectual tradition, their philosophical views and. Tragedy, recognition, and the death of god represents an important addition to williams distinguished studies of hegel. While hegel and nietzsche worked within the same intellectual tradition, their philosophical views and metaphilosophical commitments are often. Studies in hegel and nietzsche, oxford university press, 2012. Hegel s analysis of desire, the need to raise parochial self certainty to public, intersubjective truth, the life and death struggle for recognition, the constitution of the slave as the one who fears death and who works off his fear, and the final selfsubversion of mastery are important themes for critical theory from marx through habermas. Hegel retrieves the classical christian theology of the cross that has been obscured by christian appropriation of platonic metaphysics that suppresses the tragic. Then it enjoyed new vigour, perhaps to compensate for, or help explain, the dearth of genuine tragic literature, either in the novel or in the theatre. In saying this nietzsche meant that society no longer had a use for god. Nietzsche opens the first chapter of the birth of tragedywith a statement that appears in some ways to be the primary intuition guiding the reader through his reflections on the origin and the death of tragic art. For nietzsche, prometheus, not oedipus, is the archetypal tragic hero. Death mans negativity in the lectures of 18051806, at the moment of his thoughts full maturity, during the period when he was writing the phenomenology of spirit, hegel expressed in these terms the black character of humanity.
Hegel and nietzsche on thought, freedom, and the labour. In his ending nietzsche finds the justice which he asserts tragedy must uphold, for the endless suffering of the hero is matched by the extreme plight of the gods themselves, on the brink of their extinction brought. Prometheus stole fire from heaven to warm and illuminate humankind, for which he was punished eternally. Some of his other books include tragedy, recognition, and the death of god. While many cultures have developed forms that provoke this paradoxical response, the term tragedy often refers to a specific tradition of drama that has played a unique and important role historically in the selfdefinition of. Hegel responds to the death of god implicit in the kantian frame with a reconstruction and renewal of critical metaphysics, and with a theology based on a. Studies in hegel and nietzsche, oxford university press, 2012, 410pp. The union of god and death expressing divine love is for hegel the basic speculative intuition. Williams, r 2012 tragedy, recognition, and the death of god.
Third, while the moral god is dead, this does not put an end to the god question. Pdf culture and the death of god download full pdf book. Hegel and nietzsche on thought, freedom, and the labour of. Greek drama in its original forms and as reread by hegel and nietzsche, and the story of jesus so that one must conclude that tragedy is a. Williams is professor emeritus of germanic studies, philosophy, and religious studies at the university of illinois at chicago. Williams challenges the view that they are mutually exclusive. Abbreviations of frequently cited works british academy. The completion of history is not merely impossible but undesirable, as. Fichte and hegel on the other state university of new york press, 1992, and hegel s ethics of recognition university of california press, 1998.
This chapter examines hegels concept of tragedy from his early theological writings, through the phenomenology of spirit to his lectures on aesthetics. First, hegel and nietzsche express and define modern interest in tragedy as a philosophical topic. The locus of tragedy studies in contemporary phenomenology arthur n. Awarded best first book by the foundations of political theory. Hegel and nietzsche are two of the most important figures in philosophy and religion. If the moral god is dead, what sort of theodicy is possible. Although theologians since friedrich nietzsche have occasionally used the phrase god is dead to reflect increasing. Theogenesis, divine suffering, demythologizing the demonic 9. The argument advanced in this essay is that hegel and nietzsches method of critical enquiry is not only consonant but embraces a concept of practical. In hegel s view the essence of tragedy is conflict, not a moral conflict between right and wrong, but a conflict.
Kants restriction of cognition to finitude is for nietzsche an opening to tragedy, and kants view that theology is a subjective postulate of morality is for hegel the death of god. This paper attempts in a preliminary way to bring out the pragmatics or performativity in hegels conception of tragedy and the tragic in the phenomenology of spirit. Death of god theology refers to a range of ideas by various theologians and philosophers that try to account for the rise of secularity and abandonment of traditional beliefs in god. Hegel and nietzsche on thought, freedom, and the labour of the.
Hegel on the proofs and personhood of god reading religion. In the original, nietzsche used a semibiblical style to proclaim his opposition to christian morality and tradition, with many blasphemous references to god. Pdf culture and the death of god download full pdf. Studies in hegel and nietzsche, oxford oxford university press 2012, xi. This chapter compares hegel and nietzsche on the topic of master and slave. The argument advanced in this essay is that hegel and nietzsches method of critical enquiry is not only consonant but embraces a concept of practical freedom that for both philosophers tethers the. Review of tragedy, recognition, and the death of god. Nietzsche on the death of god and eternal recurrence 10. This paper traces the origins of the phrase god is dead. The historical process is a rational process that reached its zenith in hegels own time. This implies a dipolar, panentheistic concept of a tragic, suffering god, who risks, loves, and reconciles. Though this book is primarily about hegel and the philosophy of religion, it also examines the relationship between hegel and nietzsche. Connecting the philosophical ideas of hegel, nietzsche and derrida to the political ideologies of happiness, new york london new. The theme of god s death became more explicit in the theosophism of the 18th and 19thcentury mystic william blake.
They posit that god has either ceased to exist or in some way accounted for such a belief. The philosophy of spirit as an account of freedom 21 4. This chapter focuses on hegel s treatment of the death of god as an affirmative theological thesis. It explicates how and in what sense hegel s investigation in tragedy parallels the development of his philosophy from his early theological writings to his system of absolute idealism, and thereby defends the view that this investigation is linked to a concern with politics. The notion of the death of god is usually associated with nietzsche who. Hegels account of selfconsciousness in chapter iv of his phenomenology of spirit is the most influential, and perhaps the most insightful, passage in his works. Nietzsche and the death of god nietzsches proclamation of the death of god occurs in its fullest form as. Tragedy critical theory in the 20th century and beyond. An interpretation of nietzsches thought princeton university press, 2012. Tragedy tragedy critical theory in the 20th century and beyond. Article information, pdf download for hegel and nietzsche on. Williams offers a bold new account of divergences and convergences in the work of hegel and nietzsche.
The transformations of tragedy christian influences from. He is past president of the hegel society of america 19982000. Studies in hegel and nietzsche oxford university press, 2012, recognition. The chapter examines gilles deleuzes claim that hegel and nietzsche are opposites and that hegels recognition is inherently servile in nietzsches sense.
We have gained much for the science of aesthetics, once we perceive not merely by. Williams, tragedy, recognition, and the death of god. Nietzsche recognised the stark implications of this position. Oct 25, 2017 nietzsches death of god is altogether different from hegels explicitly protestantized death of god theology in due time we shall examine what nietzsche truly meant when he proclaimed in the gay science that god is dead and we have killed him.
In his intricately engraved illuminated books, blake sought to throw off the dogmatism of his contemporary christianity and, guided by a lifetime of vivid visions, examine the dark, destructive, and apocalyptic undercurrent of theology. On nietzsches transformation of aristotles greatness of soul. Hegel rejects dantes divine comedy, because in it the absolute exists without serious opposition. Hegels analysis of desire, the need to raise parochial self certainty to public, intersubjective truth, the life and death struggle for recognition, the constitution of the slave as the one who fears death and who works off his fear, and the final selfsubversion of mastery are important themes for critical theory from marx through habermas. Theology must incorporate the death of god as its own theme. Hegel stheoryoftragedy bvsalvatorerusso hegel stheoryoftragedy,likethatofaristotle,isanintegral partofhiswholephilosophy. His publications include tragedy, recognition, and the death of god. Thus, for nietzsche, the death of god meant an eclipse of this sun which would thus precipitate an unparalleled crisis for modernity. The divided individual in the political thought of g. Moral implications of lordship and bondage dialectic. Death of god and recognition of the self request pdf. Beyond aristocracy and democracy in the early period. It is hegel who articulated concepts that we have all inherited in the present. Georg wilhelm friedrich hegel is probably the most important and influential philosopher of the last 200 years.
But the death of the animal is the becoming of consciousness. Christian influences from early modern to modern explores the influence of christian theology and culture upon the development of postclassical western tragedy. Harris excludes the tragic tradition and serious otherness, and takes hegel in the direction of spinozas vision sub specie aeternitatis where evil finally disappears. Oxford university press 20 the inseparability of love and. Defining his own philosophical practice as a yeasaying to opposition and war ecce homo, nietzsche engages in a rigorous discipline of thought that proceeds on the dialectical principle of affirmative negation, thereby recuperating what hegel in his phenomenology of spirit refers to as the labour of the negative. God was, as a cultural fact, cognitively superfluous. For hegel masterslave results from the struggle for recognition. This chapter examines hegel s concept of tragedy from his early theological writings, through the phenomenology of spirit to his lectures on aesthetics. Hegel and nietzsche on thought, freedom, and the labour of the negative show all authors.
The present study is dedicated to the different interpretations of greek tragedy proposed in the writing of g. This book explores convergences between hegel and nietzsche on four themes. Williams tragedy, recognition, and the death of god. The absence or presence of faith makes no difference to humanity and thus belief in god is redundant. Hegel agrees with nietzsche that the destruction of the hero, whose onesided action threatens to destroy ethical life, is necessary, and is a healing, not as a fusion with primal being but rather the upholding of the essential rights and institutions of ethical life, the one as counterbalanced by the other. Errol harris and iwan iljin offer divergent accounts of hegel s theodicy, neither of which adequately captures hegel s thought. The argument advanced in this essay is that hegel and nietzsches method. In hegels view the essence of tragedy is conflict, not a moral conflict between right and wrong, but a conflict. Robert williams, tragedy, recognition, and the death of god. Download pdf tragedy in hegel s early theological writings. Christs disciples found themselves in a tragic situation. Through the action of the tragic hero the main institutions of ethical life, the family and the state, come into conflict. Pdf love power and justice download full pdf book download. The chapter examines gilles deleuzes claim that hegel and nietzsche are opposites and that hegel s recognition is inherently servile in nietzsche s sense.
1463 242 202 1374 711 428 282 151 125 719 971 1129 304 247 223 1328 1462 731 95 1341 1114 1267 696 294 205 28 844 1078 1010 587 969 878 363 11 1111 877 384